Nine Senators Press CFTC Chair Selig to Withdraw Prediction Market Geofencing Interpretation
Nine Democratic senators led by Adam Schiff asked CFTC Chair Michael Selig on 16 November to withdraw or freeze its 5 November geofencing interpretation.

Nine Democratic senators led by California's Adam Schiff wrote to Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman Michael Selig on Monday 16 November 2026, asking him to withdraw the agency's 5 November geofencing interpretation or freeze it until related litigation ends.
The letter targets guidance that tells exchanges to stop blocking prediction-market contracts in states where courts or regulators have restricted them. It also opens a records request, giving the CFTC until 23 November to confirm it is preserving documents.
What the CFTC's interpretation says
The 5 November document interprets Commission Regulation 38.151(b), the impartial-access rule that governs designated contract markets (DCMs), the CFTC-registered exchanges that list event contracts. According to reporting by Gaming.net, it directs DCMs to stop geofencing certain event-contract markets, meaning restricting access by geographic location.
Selig's stated rationale is that derivatives markets "must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale." Geofencing is the tool platforms have used to comply with state-level bans and court orders, so the interpretation cuts directly against how several operators are currently restricted.
What the senators are asking
The signers are all eight senators from California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, plus Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota, the ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee. Their requests fall into three groups.
| Request | Detail |
|---|---|
| Primary demand | Withdraw the interpretation, or freeze it until litigation ends |
| Records | Preserve all records and communications on these topics from 1 January 2025 to the present |
| Deadline | Confirm preservation by 23 November 2026 |
| Fallback | State that three categories of geographic restriction, including those adopted to comply with court orders and gaming laws, do not violate Regulation 38.151(b) |
The letter is framed as a congressional inquiry. It does not bind the CFTC, according to DeFiRate, but it gives prediction-market critics a concrete oversight issue ahead of Democrats' takeover of Congress.
The senators' legal argument
The letter says courts have ordered platforms to stop offering various prediction contracts in Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and on the land of two California tribes. It adds that courts have imposed geofencing requirements. The senators argue the CFTC "now appears to be encouraging" platforms to offer prohibited contracts "in contempt of these court orders" while cases are active, according to CoinDesk and Raising the Game.
The senators also lean on appellate rulings. They cite Sixth and Ninth Circuit decisions as preserving state authority to apply gaming laws to prediction markets. They further cite a Ninth Circuit preliminary-injunction ruling that treated sports event contracts on tribal land as unauthorized Class 3 gaming under the Indian Gaming Regulatory Act (IGRA), the federal law that governs gaming on tribal lands, according to Gaming.net.
SBC Americas described the letter as a warning shot, and the senators' concern about coordination between the agency and operators is theirs, not a finding by any court.
How this fits the wider CFTC push
The letter lands as the CFTC is pressing a federal-preemption position on several fronts. The agency and the Department of Justice sued Louisiana to void an emergency order against Kalshi, Polymarket and other platforms, a dispute that began when Kalshi sued Louisiana officials in federal court. The CFTC also sued Arkansas to block a state lawsuit over sports event contracts.
On the rulemaking side, the agency proposed placing event contracts inside the swap definition, with comments due 18 November. States are moving in the opposite direction: Ohio told its gaming licensees to cut ties with prediction markets by 30 October or risk their licenses.
What operators and licensees should watch
- The CFTC's reply by 23 November. Confirmation of record preservation is the first measurable response, and silence would itself be a signal.
- Whether the interpretation is withdrawn, frozen or clarified. The senators' fallback would carve court-ordered and state-law restrictions out of the impartial-access rule.
- Court treatment of geofencing. Where judges have required geofencing, platforms face conflicting directions from a federal regulator and a court.
- Oversight after the change in congressional control. The letter indicates the senators expect to investigate how the CFTC has handled prediction markets.
Status reviewed on 18 November 2026. Dates, signers and requests come from the senators' 16 November letter and the CFTC's 5 November interpretation as reported by trade and financial outlets. More regulation news and North America coverage.
Frequently asked questions
What did the senators ask the CFTC to do?
Nine Democratic senators asked CFTC Chairman Michael Selig on 16 November 2026 to withdraw the agency's 5 November interpretation on geofencing, or freeze it until related litigation ends. They also asked the CFTC to preserve records and communications on the subject dating from 1 January 2025 and to confirm by 23 November that it is doing so.
What is the CFTC's 5 November geofencing interpretation?
It is a CFTC interpretation of Commission Regulation 38.151(b), the impartial-access rule for designated contract markets. It directs those exchanges to stop geofencing certain event-contract markets. Selig has said derivatives markets must operate on a uniform basis at a national scale, which is the rationale behind ending state-by-state restrictions.
Who signed the letter to Selig?
The signers are Adam Schiff of California, who led the effort, all eight senators from California, Michigan, Nevada and Washington, and Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota. Klobuchar is the ranking member of the Senate Agriculture Committee, which oversees the CFTC. All nine signers are Democrats.
Does the senators' letter force the CFTC to change course?
No. The letter is a congressional oversight request and does not legally bind the CFTC. Its practical weight is political: it signals that Democrats expect to scrutinize the agency's handling of prediction markets, particularly as they prepare to take control of Congress.
What fallback did the senators propose if the CFTC keeps the interpretation?
If the CFTC will not withdraw or freeze it, the senators want the agency to state that three categories of geographic restriction do not violate Regulation 38.151(b). Those categories include restrictions adopted to comply with court orders and with state gaming laws.




