Judge Broderick Sends New York's Kalshi Case Back to State Court as Senate Passes DEATH BETS Act
A federal judge remanded New York's Kalshi suit to state court on 19 November 2026, and the Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act the same day.

A federal judge in Manhattan sent the New York Attorney General's lawsuit against prediction market operator KalshiEX LLC back to state court on Thursday 19 November 2026, resetting the Kalshi case to a venue where a restraining order hearing is now set for Monday.
The same day, the U.S. Senate passed the DEATH BETS Act, a bill that would bar federally registered exchanges from listing contracts on war, terrorism, assassination and death. The two developments are separate, but both bear on how far prediction markets can operate under federal registration while states press gambling-law claims.
Judge Broderick remands People v. KalshiEX to state court
Judge Vernon S. Broderick of the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York (SDNY) granted the state's motion to remand in People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC, No. 1:26-cv-06550. His 19-page order directs the clerk to remand the matter immediately to the Supreme Court of New York, New York County, according to RG.org.
He also denied the state's request for attorneys' fees and costs, finding that Kalshi's arguments for removal were colorable and objectively reasonable.
According to Gaming.net, Broderick reasoned along three lines:
- Kalshi's status as a designated contract market (a futures exchange registered with the Commodity Futures Trading Commission, or CFTC) is a defense to the state's claims, not a basis for federal jurisdiction.
- States hold long-standing authority over gambling.
- He agreed with an earlier New York federal ruling that the Commodity Exchange Act leaves room for state regulation.
The ruling does not decide whether federal law preempts New York's claims. It decides only where the dispute is heard.
What the Attorney General alleges and where the case stands
Attorney General Letitia James filed the suit on 31 July 2026 under Executive Law §63(12), and Kalshi removed it to federal court the same day. The state moved to remand on 7 August, according to Gaming.net. The complaint alleges Kalshi runs an unlicensed gambling business, including service to users under 21 and marketing on college campuses, according to RG.org and SBC Americas. The state seeks forfeiture of gains, restitution and fines of three times gains, per NewsNation. These are allegations; no court has ruled on them.
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 24 October 2025 | New York State Gaming Commission cease-and-desist letter |
| 7 July 2026 | Judge Torres denies Kalshi's preliminary injunction against enforcement of New York gambling law |
| 31 July 2026 | AG files suit; Kalshi removes it the same day |
| 7 August 2026 | State moves to remand |
| About early November 2026 | Second Circuit denies Kalshi an injunction pending appeal in the separate federal case |
| 19 November 2026 | Broderick remands the case; fee request denied |
| 19 November 2026 (late) | Kalshi's counsel at Milbank writes to Justice Melissa Crane |
| 20 November 2026 | AG asks state court for a show-cause order and TRO |
| 23 November 2026, 11:30am ET | State court hearing |
Kalshi's lawyers asked Justice Crane not to issue any ex parte temporary restraining order (TRO) without hearing from the company, warning that an order could shut the exchange down nationwide, according to crypto.news and NewsNation. The earlier TRO application was denied as moot after the remand, and the Attorney General can renew it, crypto.news reported.
Also on Friday, a federal judge rejected a CFTC bid to block New York enforcement, according to Reuters as relayed by Gizmodo. The Torres and Second Circuit rulings sit alongside the injunction denial covered in Judge McMahon's refusal to block New York from applying gambling law to Novig's sports contracts.
The wider court map for event contracts
The New York result adds to a split across jurisdictions. According to LegalSportsBetting.com, the Sixth Circuit held in September that Kalshi's sports contracts are not swaps, while the Third Circuit ruled for Kalshi against New Jersey. New Jersey's certiorari petition is Flaherty v. KalshiEX, No. 26-299.
Elsewhere, a federal court in Illinois took the opposite direction for operators, as seen when Judge Pacold enjoined Illinois licensing and tax rules on sports event contracts. Federal agencies have also gone on offense: the CFTC sued Arkansas to block a state action against Kalshi, and the CFTC and Department of Justice sued Louisiana over an emergency order against Kalshi, Polymarket and others. On the criminal side, Utah filed 14 charges against Kalshi and its co-founders; those too are allegations.
Senate passes the DEATH BETS Act
The Senate passed S. 4035, the DEATH BETS Act, on Thursday 19 November 2026. Sen. John Curtis's office said the chamber "unanimously passed" the bill, with Sen. Adam Schiff securing passage by unanimous consent. It was a voice vote, so no individual tally exists, according to LegalSportsBetting.com and RG.org.
The bill amends the Commodity Exchange Act to bar CFTC-registered entities from listing or clearing contracts involving terrorism, assassination, war or an individual's death, per the Curtis release.
According to RG.org and LegalSportsBetting.com, the passed text differs from the March original in three ways:
| Provision | Passed text |
|---|---|
| Scope | Covers only contracts that "expressly reference" the listed subjects |
| War | Names military operations of the U.S. Armed Forces |
| Death | Reaches events expected to resolve principally on a death |
The Schiff-Curtis substitute amendment adds a rule of construction: existing law on other event contracts, including "gaming," stays as it is. The bill does not address sports contracts. Curtis said those would be covered by a separate Prediction Markets Are Gambling Act that he and Schiff sponsor.
What happens next for operators
The DEATH BETS Act now goes to the House. According to LegalSportsBetting.com, the House companion, H.R. 7942 from Rep. Levin, has not moved since 3 April. The bill lapses unless the House acts by 3 January 2027, and the House would need to pass S. 4035 without changes.
For exchanges and platforms offering event contracts, the near-term calendar is the Monday hearing in New York County, where Justice Crane will take up the Attorney General's request. For compliance teams, the practical points are:
- State-court proceedings on gambling-law claims will not wait for federal preemption questions to resolve.
- Contracts tied to death, war or terrorism face a federal bar if the House acts, regardless of the sports-contract fight.
- The certiorari petition in Flaherty v. KalshiEX could bring the circuit split to the Supreme Court.
Status reviewed on 21 November 2026. Court dates and rulings come from press reports of the proceedings, while the Senate vote details come from Sen. Curtis's release. More regulation news and North America coverage.
Frequently asked questions
Why was the New York Kalshi case sent back to state court?
Judge Vernon S. Broderick granted the New York Attorney General's motion to remand on 19 November 2026. According to Gaming.net, he treated Kalshi's federal designated-contract-market status as a defense rather than a ground for federal jurisdiction, and he cited states' long-standing authority over gambling.
When is the next hearing in the New York v. Kalshi case?
A hearing on the Attorney General's request for a show-cause order and temporary restraining order is set for 11:30am ET on Monday 23 November 2026 in the Supreme Court of New York, New York County. Justice Melissa Crane is presiding over the application.
What does the DEATH BETS Act do?
S. 4035 amends the Commodity Exchange Act to bar CFTC-registered entities from listing or clearing contracts that expressly reference terrorism, assassination, war, U.S. Armed Forces military operations, or events expected to resolve principally on an individual's death. It does not change existing law on other event contracts, including gaming.
Does the DEATH BETS Act ban sports event contracts?
No. The bill covers war, terrorism, assassination and death contracts only, and its rule of construction leaves existing law on other event contracts unchanged. Sen. John Curtis said sports contracts would fall under a separate measure he and Sen. Adam Schiff have introduced, the Prediction Markets Are Gambling Act.
Will the DEATH BETS Act become law?
The Senate passed it on 19 November 2026 and it now goes to the House. According to LegalSportsBetting.com, the House must pass S. 4035 unchanged by 3 January 2027 or it lapses. The House companion, H.R. 7942 by Rep. Levin, has not moved since 3 April.
- Kalshi
- New York
- Prediction Markets
- CFTC
- Event Contracts
- Federal Court
- Prediction Market Regulation
- Legal Case




