Chile Supreme Court Tells Senate Its Site-Blocking Bill Is Unnecessary, Citing Existing Court Powers

Chile's Supreme Court told the Senate that Boletín 18.699-07, a bill on enforcing website-blocking orders, looks redundant and sits in the wrong code.

Neoclassical courthouse in Santiago at dusk with the Andes behind and legal documents on a desk

Chile's Supreme Court told the Senate in an opinion dated 12 November 2026 that a bill to enforce website-blocking orders appears unnecessary, because judges already hold the powers it would create. Chilean media reported the opinion, Oficio N° 314-2026, on 18 November.

The bill, Boletín N° 18.699-07, began as a parliamentary motion and is in its first constitutional stage in the Senate. It has no legislative urgency. The Senate asked for the Court's view by Oficio 313/SEC/26 of 30 September 2026, signed by acting President Iván Moreira Barros and acting Secretary General Julio Cámara Oyarzo, under Article 77 of the Constitution and Article 16 of Ley 18.918, the organic law of the Congress.

What the Supreme Court found

The Court's central finding is that the bill does not fit the problem it is meant to solve. The stated problem is online betting platforms using technical means to stay reachable despite judicial blocking orders. Yet none of the three proposed articles mentions betting or gambling. They would apply to any blocking order against any website or platform.

The justices also said the articles "parecen innecesarios y sobreabundantes" (seem unnecessary and superfluous) given enforcement rules already in Título XIX, Libro I of the Código de Procedimiento Civil, the Civil Procedure Code. The existing powers it cited are:

  • Article 76 of the Constitution, which vests courts with the power to have their rulings enforced.
  • Article 11 of the Código Orgánico de Tribunales, the courts' organic code.
  • Articles 235 to 238 of the Código de Procedimiento Civil.
  • Article 240, which already lets a court undo anything done against an executed order and punishes breach with "reclusión menor en su grado medio a máximo", a prison term.

The criticism is conditional rather than a rejection of the aim. If the articles stay general, they look redundant. If they were narrowed to online gambling, the Court said, they would still sit in the wrong code. Book I of the Código de Procedimiento Civil holds rules common to all procedures and also applies to criminal cases, so very specific internet-provider rules would distort it. The Court added that the problem "puede estar en otros factores" unrelated to any lack of court enforcement powers.

What the bill would change

The bill is a single article that inserts three new provisions into the Código de Procedimiento Civil.

Provision Subject
Article 238 bis Lets courts order the measures needed to enforce blocking orders on internet access providers. Sets what orders must contain and requires providers to block within the deadline and report compliance. Allows an order to be extended to new domains, subdomains or mirror sites if a technical link is shown and lawful services are not affected.
Article 238 ter Covers non-compliance by internet providers, including court requests for reports and coercive measures.
Article 238 quáter Covers circumvention by the platform operators themselves.

The mirror-site extension is the provision most relevant to unlicensed betting brands, which often reappear under new domains after a block.

How the opinion was produced

Date Step
30 September 2026 Senate leadership requests the Court's opinion (Oficio 313/SEC/26)
9 November 2026 Full Court (Tribunal Pleno) discusses the bill, with acting President Gloria Ana Chevesich Ruiz presiding and 11 other justices
11 November 2026 Resolution dated
12 November 2026 Oficio N° 314-2026 sent to the Senate
18 November 2026 Chilean outlets report the opinion

Where the Court points instead

The Court suggested the Ley General de Telecomunicaciones (Ley 18.168), which governs internet providers, as a more natural home for any new rules. That law gives sanctioning powers to the Transport and Telecommunications Ministry through its Subsecretaría. The justices also said Ley 19.995, the casino law, and the Superintendencia de Casinos de Juego it creates, could not be ruled out as part of the answer.

Judges have in practice already ordered blocks. The Supreme Court has granted protection (recurso de protección) petitions requiring internet providers to cut access to unlicensed betting sites, including a case brought by the state lottery operator Polla Chilena de Beneficencia against the provider Mundo Pacífico, and a later case involving Lotería de Concepción. The opinion's reasoning rests on that same enforcement capacity.

Context for operators and affiliates

The opinion is advisory. Under Article 77, the Senate must consult the Court on bills that touch court organization and powers, but it is not bound by the reply. The bill remains without urgency, so no near-term change to blocking practice follows from it.

This bill is separate from the online betting regulation bill, on which the Senate Economy Committee backed amendments to ban online betting platforms, as covered in our report on the Senate committee's amendments. For the longer arc, see earlier reporting on Chile's online gambling law overhaul, the proposed responsible gambling tax and the dropped legal case against foreign operators.

For operators serving Chile without a local license, the practical read is that court-ordered blocks through protection cases remain available, and the enforcement debate is moving toward telecommunications and casino-sector regulators rather than civil procedure.

Status reviewed on 21 November 2026. The details come from the Supreme Court's Oficio N° 314-2026 and Chilean press reports of 18 November. More regulation news and Latin America coverage.

Frequently asked questions

What did Chile's Supreme Court say about the website-blocking bill?

In Oficio N° 314-2026, the Court told the Senate that the three articles proposed in Boletín N° 18.699-07 seem unnecessary and redundant. It said courts already have enforcement powers under the Código de Procedimiento Civil, that the bill never mentions betting, and that the code is the wrong place for internet-provider rules.

What is Boletín N° 18.699-07?

It is a Chilean parliamentary motion that would amend the Código de Procedimiento Civil, the Civil Procedure Code, to regulate how court orders blocking websites and online platforms are enforced. It adds Articles 238 bis, 238 ter and 238 quáter. The bill is in its first constitutional stage in the Senate with no legislative urgency.

Is the Supreme Court's opinion binding on the Chilean Senate?

No. Article 77 of the Constitution requires the Senate to consult the Supreme Court on bills touching the organization and powers of the courts, but the Court's answer is advisory. Senators can proceed with, amend or drop the bill regardless of the opinion.

Can Chilean courts already order betting sites to be blocked?

Yes. The Supreme Court has ordered internet providers to block unlicensed betting sites in protection (recurso de protección) cases, including cases brought by Polla Chilena de Beneficencia and Lotería de Concepción. In its opinion, the Court said judges already hold the enforcement tools through the Código de Procedimiento Civil.

Which law does the Supreme Court say could handle internet-provider blocking?

The Court pointed to the Ley General de Telecomunicaciones (Ley 18.168), which governs internet providers and gives sanctioning powers to the Transport and Telecommunications Ministry through its Subsecretaría. It also said the casino law, Ley 19.995, and the Superintendencia de Casinos de Juego it creates could not be ruled out.

Jerome McNamara

Jerome McNamara covers gambling regulation, legislation and enforcement for Gamingo News, with a focus on Europe and the United States.