CJEU Declines to Rule on Malta's Bill 55 as Austrian Reference Is Inadmissible
The Court of Justice found an Austrian reference on Malta's Bill 55 inadmissible on 19 November 2026, leaving the law's EU compatibility undecided.

The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) ruled on 19 November 2026 in Case C-683/24, Spielerschutz Sigma, that an Austrian court's reference on the compatibility of Malta's Bill 55 gaming amendment with EU law is inadmissible, so Luxembourg gave no answer on the substance.
The judgment leaves the provision exactly where it was before the case: not endorsed, not struck down. For operators with Maltese licenses and for litigation funders pursuing player claims, the question of whether Maltese courts may refuse to enforce foreign judgments still has no EU-level answer.
What the Court decided
The Court declared the reference from the Commercial Court, Vienna, inadmissible, according to its press release No 167/26 issued in Luxembourg on 19 November 2026. EU Law Live confirms the date and the referring court.
The reasoning is procedural. The Court said the dispute in Vienna turns on whether a legal advisor was at fault, not on whether the Maltese law is compatible with EU law, as iGamingToday reports. An answer on Maltese legislation was therefore not needed to decide the Austrian case.
That matches the view of Advocate General Emiliou, who said in an opinion of 23 April 2026 that an answer was not necessary and the reference should be inadmissible. According to the opinion, the German and Maltese governments had also argued the request was inadmissible.
How an advisor dispute reached the EU's top court
Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH is an Austrian company that funds claims by Austria-resident online gambling players against operators holding Maltese licenses. The chain of events, as described by the Court:
| Step | Event |
|---|---|
| 1 | Sigma obtained a legal advisor's opinion on whether the Maltese amendment was compatible with EU law |
| 2 | A Maltese court rejected Sigma's request to recognize and enforce an Austrian judgment, relying on the amendment |
| 3 | Sigma sued the advisor in the Commercial Court, Vienna, for the fees it paid and for losses from funding proceedings after the opinion |
| 4 | The Vienna court referred questions on Maltese law's compatibility with EU law to the CJEU |
| 5 | Advocate General opinion on 23 April 2026; judgment on 19 November 2026 |
Because the claim is against the advisor, the Vienna court's task is to decide whether the advice was negligent. The CJEU concluded that this does not require it to rule on Malta's law.
What Bill 55 does
Malta introduced the provision into its Gaming Act in June 2023 through an amendment tabled as Bill 55. It directs Maltese courts to refuse, as a matter of public policy, to recognize or enforce a foreign judgment that meets three conditions:
- it upholds a claim against a Maltese-licensed operator;
- it is based on the operator's services being illegal in another EU Member State; and
- the services were lawful under Maltese law.
Gamingo covered the proposal when it was first floated in proposed Maltese legislation shielding operators from foreign accountability, and later reported Dutch legal experts challenging the bill. The provision is referred to as Article 56A of the Gaming Act by iGamingExpert; Gamingo has also tracked EU legal action over Article 56A.
The Advocate General's alternative view
Had the Court found the reference admissible, Advocate General Emiliou proposed that the provision be found "manifestly incompatible" with the Brussels I bis Regulation, the EU rules on recognizing and enforcing judgments between Member States. He said Malta cannot rely on the public-policy clause or on the freedom to provide services to justify it. He also said the "country of origin" principle does not apply to online gambling, and that states need not recognize other states' gambling licenses.
An Advocate General's opinion is non-binding, and this one was given only in the alternative. The Court adopted none of it. Reports framing the judgment as a win for Malta or for operators overstate what was decided; so would a reading that treats the ruling as a defeat for the law. The Advocate General's critical assessment remains the only judicial opinion on the substance.
What happens next
The iGamingExpert site expects the case to return to the Vienna Commercial Court for the damages claim against the advisor, and argues that the ruling weakens Malta's reliance on the provision. That is an interpretation rather than a holding of the Court. iGaming Business reports that a CJEU press officer said the judgment did not address compatibility.
For the market, the practical position is unchanged:
- Maltese courts can continue to apply the provision when asked to enforce foreign judgments.
- A future case, with a dispute that genuinely requires an answer on Maltese law, would be needed to put the question to the CJEU again.
- Operators and funders will keep weighing how national courts in other Member States respond to the provision, a theme also seen in the ECJ clash over a German player's loss and in Tipico's CEO rejecting the Maltese legal shield.
No statement from the Malta Gaming Authority or the Maltese government on the judgment has been published in the coverage reviewed by Gamingo.
Status reviewed on 19 November 2026. Dates, parties and procedural details come from Court of Justice press releases No 167/26 and No 65/26. More regulation news and EMEA coverage.
Frequently asked questions
What did the CJEU decide in Case C-683/24 Spielerschutz Sigma?
On 19 November 2026 the Court of Justice held that the reference from the Commercial Court, Vienna, is inadmissible. It therefore did not answer the questions on whether Malta's Bill 55 amendment to its Gaming Act is compatible with EU law. The substantive question remains undecided at EU level.
Did the EU court uphold or strike down Malta's Bill 55?
Neither. The judgment declared the Austrian reference inadmissible and did not assess the Maltese provision. Bill 55 has been neither endorsed nor invalidated. Maltese courts continue to apply the provision, while the only judicial view on its substance remains the non-binding opinion of Advocate General Emiliou.
What does Bill 55 do?
Introduced into Malta's Gaming Act in June 2023, Bill 55 requires Maltese courts to refuse, on public-policy grounds, to recognize or enforce a foreign judgment that upholds a claim against a Maltese-licensed operator, is based on the services being illegal in another Member State, and concerns services lawful under Maltese law.
Why was the Austrian reference inadmissible?
The Court found that the Vienna dispute turns on whether the legal advisor was at fault, not on whether Malta's law complies with EU law. An answer was therefore not needed to resolve the case. Advocate General Emiliou had reached the same conclusion in his opinion of 23 April 2026.
Who is Spielerschutz Sigma?
Spielerschutz Sigma Prozessfinanzierungs GmbH is an Austrian company that funds claims by Austria-resident online gambling players against operators holding Maltese licenses. It sued its legal advisor in Vienna over fees and losses after a Maltese court refused to recognize and enforce an Austrian judgment, relying on Bill 55.
- Bill 55
- Court Ruling
- European Court of Justice
- ECJ
- Malta
- Malta gambling
- Cross-Border Enforcement
- EU gaming regulation




